Are you looking for a comparison between the two highly comfortable memory foam mattresses? Then you have come to the right place! As you must be familiar that most of the people out there are extremely satisfied using these two memory foam mattresses, Zinus and Tuft and Needle. Not only they are affordable, but also provide the same luxurious sleeping experience like the other expensive brands.
Hence, we decided to bring you the comparison between the most popular mattresses of these two companies, Mint mattress of Tuft and needle Vs Cooling gel memory foam of Zinus.
Let us first tell you about the major differences and similarities amongst these two mattress.
Key Similarities
- Both consist of memory foam
- Both have really good motion isolation
- Both have 100 year night trial
- Both have 10 year warranty
Key Differences
- Zinus mattress foam has many thickness options
- Zinus cooling gel memory foam mattress is less expensive than Tuft and needle Mint mattress
- Tuft and needle mattress uses Graphite in their mattress
- Zinus mattress uses Green tea for the good odour
Zinus Construction
- It is 8 inch tall
- Has a knitted jacquard cover
- First layer is 2” gel memory foam
- Second layer is5” inch comfort foam
- The last layer is 4.5” high density base support foam
Tuft and Needle Construction
- It is 12” tall
- Cover is made up of knit polyester
- First layer is 3” of brands Tuft and Needle Adaptive foam
- Second layer is 2” section of poly foam which contains the cooling beads
- Final base layer is of 6.5” high density poly foam
Construction Differences
Let’s start from Zinus cooling gel memory foam’s cover. It is a knitted fabric designed to keep you cool and hence it is totally perfect for those who are not fond of sweaty wakeups. Then comes its most popular layer, the cooling gel memory foam which, as the name suggests, also aids in sleeping cool all night. Further this same layer has a gel foam which is able to contour your body according to your shape. Then comes 1.5” comfort layer which lets you sleep comfortable and cosy in the bed all night. Finally the high density base foam layer provides the best support to the upper two layers, so that your body feels balanced on the bed even when you move here and there while sleeping.
On the other hand, when you look at the knit cover of Tuft and needle Mint mattress, it has a thick and cosy feel. Its next 3” adaptive foam layer has a bit slower response to pressure by which it provides plenty of contour to your body. Next in the line is its 2” layer of poly foam which consists of cooling beads which gets activated when pressure is applied on the mattress. Lastly, the base layer of this mattress is of 6.5” which is designed to give adequate stability to the mattress.
Firmness/Feel Differences
The Zinus cooling gel memory foam mattress is rated 6/10 on the firmness scale which makes it a medium firm mattress. A very interesting thing about these mattresses is that it has various options for thickness and as the thickness increases so does the firmness of mattress making it plusher.
On the other hand if we talk about tuft and needle Mint mattress, it has also been rated 6/10 on the firmness scale which makes it closer to a softer side. Hence adding a gentle feel to it.
Sleep Experience
Zinus cooling gel memory foam provides chill throughout the night so that you are well-rested on a hot summer night. The cooling gel memory foam is specially designed for this purpose so that you can have a perfect sleep experience. On the other hand the Mint mattress of Tuft and needle has 30% graphite which gives excellent breath-ability to the mattress. Hence both of these mattress has a really good sleep experience.
Temperature Control
Even though it not clear that the Gel layer of memory foam in the Zinus mattress let the heat escape or not, but it surely is able to resist body heat so that the person can sleep cool all night. Further, its cover also has the ability to keep you cool at night.
On the other hand, the sink age in the comfort layer of Tuft and Needle Mint mattress could lead to some overheating, but the company has infused this layer with graphite which helps is absorbing and dissipating the heat as you sleep through the night.
This means that both of these mattresses are good at regulating temperature, regardless of how they do it.
Motion Isolation
When the top two layers of Zinus cooling gel memory foam mattress are combined with its base layer, you get a mattress which is able to absorb tremendous amount of motion and give you a comfortable sleep. Same goes for the Tuft and Needle Mint mattress which is also capable of absorbing and dissipating motion. So you won’t be bothered if your partner moves at night with either of the mattresses.
Pressure Relief
The first two layers of Zinus mattress have been highlighted to relieve pressure points for all back and stomach sleepers. Its 4.5” high density base foam also has some ability to provide some extra pressure relief supporting your body weight.
Whereas, Tuft and needle Mint mattress is ideal for back and stomach sleepers, providing great pressure relief in the lumbar region. Moreover, it is an all foam mattress, ensuring that side sleepers have a great experience as it will contour their body right.
Resilience and Bounce
Not much has been mentioned about the bounce of these two mattresses. Both fall in the range of medium firm on the firmness scale and both are all foam mattresses. So people who like to have a bouncy mattress should consider coiled mattress rather than all foam mattresses.
Edge Support
One of the drawbacks of Zinus Cooling gel memory foam mattress is that it does not excel much at providing edge support. So heavier sleepers would like to look for coil mattresses rather than this all foam mattress.
This feature contradicts when it comes to Tuft and Needle Mint mattress as this mattress provide some real good edge support. This is impressive for couples as you can easily sleep on the edge of the mattress without fear of falling down.
Off-Gassing And Smell
Little to no smelling is reported in customer feedback of Zinus mattress. The Green tea added neutralizes the odor to give a cleaner sleep. On the other hand, feedback’s of Tuft and needle also report no smelling of the Mint mattress.
Shipping, Trial, Warranty And Returns
The policies about shipping, return and warranties about these mattresses are listed below to give you a general idea and help you decide.
| AMERISLEEP AS3 | LEESA ORIGINAL | |
|---|---|---|
| Shipping | Free | Free Contagious 48 States |
| Night Trials | 100 Nights | 100 Nights |
| Warranty | 10 Years | 10 Years |
| Type | Foam | Foam |
Pick The Zinus If …
- You like sleeping cool at night: its cooling knot cover and cooling gel memory foam layer helps dissipate heat so that you can have cool night sleep
- You cannot withstand any sort of smelling: green tea is especially added which aids in neutralising the odour.
- You don’t care much about edge support: as mentioned before, edge support is not something Zinus Cooling gel memory foam is good at.
- You are fond of all foam mattress
Pick The Tuft and Needle If …
- You are a stomach and back sleeper: as it provides great pressure relief in the lumbar area
- If you are a strict side sleeper: as this mattress contours the body perfectly
- You like sleeping cool: 30% graphite is added to dissipate heat absorbed by the mattress.
- You like all foam mattress
Prices, Sizes And Value
The prices are extremely important for comparison. The table below shows the prices and different sizes of Zinus and Tuft & Needle mattress
| Mattress Size | ZINUS | TUFT & NEEDLE |
|---|---|---|
| Twin | $172 | $536 |
| Twin XL | N/A | $581 |
| Full | $218 | $761 |
| Queen | $246 | $896 |
| King | $295 | $1031 |
| California King | $295 | $1031 |
Now it all comes down to you to make the right choice for yourself. If you are on a budget and still looking for a good sleeping experience, we prefer you to go for Zinus. If you want to relieve those back aces, go for tuft and needle Mint mattress as it is the ideal mattress for relieving pressure points.
