Comparison: Lucid vs Zinus vs Signature Sleep vs Tuft & Needle

When it comes to enjoying a full night of quality sleep, you shouldn’t cut corners with your mattress choice. Pick the wrong mattress, and your nights could become a nightmare. You don’t want to feel uncomfortable, you want the best experience when you go to sleep. No back or neck pain in the morning, no feeling of stiffness, no need to crack your bones or stretch to relieve the tension. Only relaxation and a great mood for a fresh start in the morning. The right mattress can do all that for you and so much more.

You need around 8 hours of quality sleep every night to feel good during the day, be productive and in a good mood. Choosing the best mattress isn’t as easy as it seems, but if you find the one that is just perfect for you, your life will improve even more than you expect.

How To Choose The Best Mattress

Even if there are some general rules about what is good and what is bad for your sleep, preferences might vary from person to person. Things like your favorite sleeping position or your body weight will influence the kind of mattress that best adapts to you. Before choosing your mattress, you need to understand what are your sleeping needs.

Here is a quick guide on the main aspects you need to bear in mind when shopping for mattresses.

  • Thickness: Mattresses are classified by thickness, but in many cases, this is not the most important feature to focus on. An adult should sleep on a mattress at least 6” thick. Thickness over 10” or 12” usually doesn’t add much because the body doesn’t weigh enough for it to make any difference. We suggest you focus on other features such as firmness and size.
  • Firmness: This is how soft or hard the mattress is. Soft mattresses are more adaptable but rarely provide enough support for your spine, so you are more likely to get back pain in the morning. On the other hand, hard mattresses often provide better support but are more likely to be uncomfortable if you sleep on your side or have a wavy spine. We suggest you aim at a medium firmness mattress if you sleep on your back or side, and a harder mattress if you sleep on your belly.
  • Size: Mattresses often come in many sizes and you can choose the one you need. The size of the mattress will depend on the size of your bed. For two people in the same bed, you will need a queen or king-sized mattress. A single adult can sleep on a full mattress. Children and young teenagers will do with a twin-sized mattress.
  • Materials: Most mattresses nowadays are made of foam and/or memory foam, springs or latex. Each material has their pros and cons, so no one is objectively better than the other. Memory foam can adapt to your body shape and help fight posture-related back pain but provides less support. Springs are the best for support and firmness but could be too hard or uncomfortable for heavy people. Latex is the best for support and durability, however it is the most expensive option so it’s rarely budget-friendly.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: They say that you get what you pay, and when it comes to mattresses, in some cases this can be true. Cheaper mattresses could be of bad quality, and you will end up needing to buy a new one in just a few weeks or months, and there go your savings. However, the most expensive mattress isn’t necessarily the best one, and inversely, there are good cheap mattresses out there that you can get for an affordable price. In this article we review some great mattress brands that offer affordable options of recognized quality that thousands of users now enjoy.

Comparing The Best Mattresses In The Market

Shopping around takes hours, and even if you do it online in the comfort of your home, it can still be tiring and confusing with all that information and all those options. But don’t worry, we have already done the hard work for you. We have checked seller’s information as well as customer reviews and feedback, and we have found the best mattress brands. Even more, we have found the very best product of each brand, and set them all up for comparison.

Signature Sleep Contour Encased Mattress, Queen, White
Zinus Memory Foam 12 Inch Green Tea Mattress, FullLUCID 12 Inch Gel Infused Memory Foam Mattress - CertiPUR-US Certified - 10-Year Warranty - QueenTUFT & NEEDLE Queen Mattress | Bed in a Box | Utilizing Proprietary T&N Adaptive Foam | Sleeps Cooler with More Pressure Relief & Support Than Memory Foam | Non-Toxic Certified | 10-Year Warranty
Signature Sleep Contour 8 Inch Independently-Encased Coil Mattress
Zinus Memory Foam 12 Inch Green Tea Mattress
LUCID 12 Inch Gel Memory Foam Mattress
Tuft & Needle Mattress, Mattress with T&N Adaptive Foam
Customer Reviews
Construction Type
Inner Spring
Memory Foam
Memory Foam
Memory Foam
75 x 39 x 8 in
80 x 60 x 6 in
80 x 60 x 12 in
60 x 80 x 10 in
Check Prices On Amazon
Check Prices On Amazon
Check Prices On Amazon
Check Prices On Amazon
Signature Sleep Contour Encased Mattress, Queen, White
  • A layer of high density foam at the top and bottom of the mattress gives you a comfortable embracing...
  • 7" 15 gauge independently encased coils provide an equal weight distribution by contouring the...
  • The reversible feature provides extra versatility enabling you to flip and rotate the mattress to...
  • Foam in this mattress is made without PBDEs, TDCPP or TCEP (“Tris”) flame retardants, ozone...
  • Product dimensions: 80"L x 60"W x 8"H. Net weight: 74.5 lbs. Shipping dimensions: 63"L x 13"W x...

Do you want to get a high-quality, all-purposes mattress that fits comfortable within your budget? Then Signature Sleep is the brand you have to go for. It is renowned as one of the most affordable brands out there, and by affordable we don’t mean cheap. You can still get restful nights of sleep on any of their products, and enjoy all the advantages of an independently-encased coil mattress.

This mattress provides excellent motion isolation thanks to its coil structure, which makes it a great choice for queen or king-sized beds. If your partner moves or gets up at night, the motion will not be transferred to your side of the bed, so you will continue sleeping like a baby. Independently-encased coils also offer great adaptability to your body shape, so you can sleep in any position and still find this mattress extremely comfortable.

Another advantage of the coil system is that it makes the mattress very breathable and cool, so if you live in a warmer area you will enjoy a fresh sleep even in the hottest nights.

This mattress has great edge support, so you can sit on the edges without fear of deforming it with your weight. You can use it to eat or to work, and even for a futon or convertible bed that doubles as sitting space.

Now with the cons. Perhaps the greatest disadvantage of this mattress is the reduced warranty, which is often only one-year limited warranty. Also, this model doesn’t offer a trial period, so you cannot just return it if you feel it’s not working for you. This mattress is affordable and generally of good quality, but if the system or the thickness is not ideal for you, the purchase of this product might be a risk.


  • Independently encased coils make it perfect for bunk beds and other beds with slats.
  • Very affordable, but still great quality.
  • Great motion isolation.
  • Suitable for all sleeping positions.
  • Cool and breathable in warm nights.
  • Strong edge support.


  • No trial period.
  • Relatively short warranty. (1-year.)
  • Might be too firm for some sleepers.
Zinus Memory Foam 12 Inch Green Tea Mattress, Full
  • Conforming Green Tea Memory Foam comfort and pressure relieving support for a better night’s...
  • 3 inches Memory Foam, 2 inches Comfort Foam, 7 inches high-density base support foam.
  • A safe and trustworthy anti-oxidant, Zinus infuses its memory foam products with natural green tea...
  • Smartly Shipped Our patented technology allows our mattresses to be efficiently compressed, rolled...
  • Mattresses typically take 48 hours to expand. They may take longer in some cases. Other factors,...

Zinus has pretty much taken over the market with its great products and its fantastic pricing. Zinus mattresses are among the most popular mattresses online and they have great customer reviews. This company started out as an outdoor furniture manufacturer but quickly became renowned for its quality mattresses. Their best piece, the Green Tea Mattress, combines the best technology, eco-friendly production and comfort insight to present an almost perfect mattress for your enjoyment. So, let’s take a look.

First of all, this mattress has four layers of different styles of foam, such as support foam on the base and memory foam on top. Memory foam is very popular because it adapts perfectly to your body and helps you sleep very comfortably at night, regardless of your sleeping position or how much you move when you rest. The airflow layers allow the mattress to breathe, so you can feel very fresh even during warm months.

All foam used in this mattress is approved by CertiPUR-US standards. CertiPUR-US is an organization that reviews and controls the quality of foam used in products. So, you can be sure your Zinus mattress is safe, healthy and high-quality.

One of the best features of this mattress is that it is infused with green tea extract and castor natural seed oil. These are natural and eco-friendly components that protect your mattress against bacteria, and the bad odor they could cause. This makes this mattress healthier and cleaner, and a perfect option for kids or people who are allergic or more sensitive to some products.

Regarding pricing, Zinus offers very affordable prices for the great quality of their products, so if you are on a budget but still can stretch a bit to get a great mattress that will last for years, then Zinus is your best option. You can also enjoy a 30-day trial and a 10-year warranty for your Zinus mattress.

The main reported disadvantage of this mattress is that it has slight movement transfer, which means that if you sleep with a partner, you might feel if the other person moves, gets up or lies down. Also, this mattress doesn’t have a firm support on the edges, so if you sit on the edge you might eventually deform the mattress; try to avoid doing this instead.


  • Its materials and production process protect the environment.
  • Memory foam provides a comfortable sleeping experience.
  • Mid layers that allow air flow make it breathable and cool at night.
  • CertiPUR-US approved.
  • Infused with green tea extract and castor natural seed oil prevents the accumulation of odor and bacteria.
  • 30-day trial and 10-year warranty.


  • Slight motion transfer reported.
  • Lacks edge support.
LUCID 12 Inch Gel Infused Memory Foam Mattress - CertiPUR-US Certified - 10-Year Warranty - Queen
  • Top layer features 3 inches of gel-infused memory foam that helps control temperature as you sleep
  • Medium feel is just right, not too firm or too soft, so you and your partner can sleep in comfort
  • Base foam layer offers deep-down support and comfort that works with memory foam to align your spine
  • Built to relieve pressure by supporting the natural curves of your head, neck, and shoulders
  • Ventilated top layer and TENCEL blend cover ensure a breathable sleep environment

This amazing product from LUCID features gel memory foam technology to provide a unique luxury feel at a more than reasonable price. If you are looking for comfort, softness and a welcoming embrace every time you are tired and go to bed, then LUCID has what you want.

The technology of this product takes the much-valued memory foam and takes it to the next level. You already know about the health and comfort benefits of memory foam, how it adapts to the natural curves of your body and helps provide proper support for your spine, neck and shoulders. Now, the gel-infused memory foam found in this mattress gives you that and so much more.

The 3” thick memory foam layer is infused with gel beads does not only adapt to your body but also keep it cool and comfortable thanks to its great breathability. It allows the perfect airflow so you can enjoy a fresh rest at night without feeling too warm or suffocated under your sheets.

Another great advantage of this gel-infused memory foam is the reduced motion transfer. Unlike other memory foam mattresses, with LUCID you can move, change positions or get up at night without your partner noticing, and if he or she does it, you will not be disturbed.

The mattress includes a soft TENCEL Lyocell blend cover that improves the experience even further. This soft cover does not only provide a more comfortable feel to your mattress, but is also very breathable and helps keep moisture under control, to prevent stains and unwelcomed bad smell.

This mattress offers a 10-year warranty.

Perhaps the only big problem this mattress has is that, due to its materials, it is not suitable for bed frames with slats. You need a box spring if you want to buy this mattress.


  • Gel-infused memory foam is breathable and cool.
  • Adapts to your body for a comfortable rest.
  • Provides proper support for neck, back and hips.
  • Reduced motion transfer for a long night of sleep.
  • Soft cover improves comfort and breathability.
  • 10-year warranty.


  • Requires a box spring if your bed doesn’t have slats.
  • Not suitable for bunk beds due to its thickness.
TUFT & NEEDLE Queen Mattress | Bed in a Box | Utilizing Proprietary T&N Adaptive Foam | Sleeps Cooler with More Pressure Relief & Support Than Memory Foam | Non-Toxic Certified | 10-Year Warranty
  • PROVEN: We're not shy to say, people love us; This mattress has 1 of the highest percentages of 5...
  • PROPRIETARY ADAPTIVE FOAM: Constructed with freshly poured T and N Adaptive foam, this mattress...
  • NOT HOT, NOT COLD, JUST RIGHT: Our high grade foam is more advanced than outdated materials such as...
  • NO RISK: Our mattress has an honest 10 year limited warranty you can actually use (no gimmicks)
  • CERTIFIED: We go the extra mile to get our mattresses Greenguard Gold, and Certi PUR certified; This...

If you want to treat yourself with a great mattress that has everything, then look no further than this fast-growing American startup called Tuft & Needle. As a company, it is young and started with a ridiculously low investment budget, but the outstanding quality of their products and their great commercial politics has made their sales and popularity skyrocket overnight. Unlike all previously mentioned mattresses, which are manufactured in China, Tuft & Needle is a 100% American product that is only found and sold online and will be delivered to your doorstep free of charge.

Perhaps the best feature of this mattress is its exclusive material, the Adaptive Foam. You will find no other mattress in the market with the same composition and performance. This mattress features a top layer of adaptive foam which is a type of memory foam infused with gel and graphite. It will work wonderfully for any sleeping position, and adapt naturally to your body providing a great sleeping experience.

Adaptive Foam is very breathable and helps you stay cool during the night, unlike other types of memory foam that allow less airflow and can be suffocating, especially if the climate is too warm. The airflow prevents the formation of bacterial colonies and the odor buildup.

This type of memory foam also isolates your movement, and offers the right balance between support and bounciness. You can sleep comfortably without the movement of the other person disturbing your rest.

The Tuft & Needle mattress comes with a 10-year worry-free warranty, and is certified by the top 3 certifying organisms in the world: Greenguard Gold, Oeko-Tex, and CertiPUR-US. This triple certification is triple guarantee that you will enjoy the best product, the safest materials and the most lasting mattress.

The products of Tuft & Needle have had a great reception within the online market, with great reviews from customers, and has been distinguished by Amazon and other big sales platforms as one of the best, if not the best, mattress you can aspire to own. Tuft & Needle only has one product, which is this adaptive foam mattress, and instead of dividing their resources among a catalogue of products, they decided to put their all into this one model. As a result, the Tuft & Needle adaptive foam mattress has won the company many awards since 2016.

There is no other way to put this. When you get a Tuft & Needle mattress, you get the best. If there is any downside to this, which is very hard to find considering how good the product is, then we would have to say it’s the price. The adaptive foam mattress is the most expensive of the four products compared here, so if you are on a strict budget, then this might not be the perfect mattress for you.


  • Free delivery to your door.
  • Exclusive Adaptive Foam is the best memory foam available.
  • Breathable and fresh.
  • Prevents odor and bacteria buildup.
  • Great movement isolation.
  • 10-year warranty.
  • Awarded, certified mattress.


  • Not suitable for a budget purchase.

As you know, choosing the best mattress for you is fundamental for your wellbeing and your health. A mattress isn’t like a table or a bookcase. If you get a bad one, you might suffer from inconveniences or just dislike the way the product looks, and worse case scenario, you will have to get rid of the piece and get a new one. However, making the wrong choice with your mattress can cost you more than that.

It is not exaggerated to say that buying the wrong mattress can damage your health. Not only improper support can give you neck pain, headaches, shoulder contractures and back pain. Not only your already existing body pain can get worse if your mattress isn’t of good quality or wisely chosen.

Your daily routine will be affected if you don’t enjoy quality sleep at night. Your productivity will decrease and your mood will get worse. Studies show that people who lack a good night of sleep have more trouble focusing on their tasks, are more irritable and impulsive, and even tend to gain weight because they eat more and get more stressed out. Children who don’t get enough rest can have trouble growing up and developing their mental and physical skills, and are more prone to tantrums and misbehavior.

With all of this said, which is the best mattress for you? In this article, we have reviewed the top products of the top 4 brands of mattresses, so any of the four that you buy will be potentially a good choice. They all have positive reviews and have been distinguished as the best of their brand. But which one is the best of all?

We have provided the information that you need to decide which mattress is the best for your needs. However, we have picked our favorite among the four. There is one mattress we consider to be worth the money, healthy, safe, comfortable and durable. But first, let’s see which is the runner-up mattress if our first choice doesn’t convince you.

This model has all it takes to be a great mattress. It is affordable and cost-effective. It has a layer of memory foam that adapts to your body and provides proper support for your weight, and the gel bean technology make it even more adaptable and breathable for a comfy night of sleep.

We like gel memory foam because it has the best memory foam can offer plus the advantages of the breathability provided by the gel technology. Also, LUCID mattresses are affordable and you get a luxury experience for a very reasonable price. If you want to feel the best for less, LUCID has the perfect balance, the best of both worlds.

You could have seen this coming from a mile away. There is no other way to put it. Despite its short run as a company and its relatively small beginning, Tuft & Needle has won its place among the top mattress manufacturers with its outstanding product. When you buy a T&N Mattress, you enjoy the exclusive technology of gel & graphite memory foam, which is to date unbeatable when it comes to quality.

It is true that Tuft & Needle is more expensive than other top mattress brands, and for that reason, we have offered LUCID as a second option that costs less but still offers many –but not all – of the great advantages you enjoy when you rest on top of a Tuft & Needle product. However, in this case, we strongly believe that, if you can afford the difference, you should stick to the best.

We have stressed how important a restful night of sleep is, and why getting proper body support and adaptability can make such a big difference in your life. Money could seem like too important right now, but even if we leave health bills aside, your wellbeing and quality of life is worth much more than two hundred dollars.

So make an investment for your own sake and your family’s sake, and get the best mattress you can find online. Tuft & Needle will never disappoint, and you will be getting a quality product you will never regret to buy.

Comments 1

  1. Jennifer Crocker says:

    We would like to purchase a Tuft & Needle Mattress in the next week. I have had 5 back surgeries and one more in the near future.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *